Galli Local
Home / Articles / Hiring help Hiring help · law firms

How to hire an SEO company for your law firm: 10 questions and a scorecard

Ten questions that show who does the work, who owns your accounts, what you'll see each month and how you leave. Each one comes with the answer to expect, the warning sign, and the rule or source behind it.

By Steven Galli, founder of Galli LocalUpdated November 2026 · 9 min read · 8 sources cited
The short answer

Hire the company that names the person on your account, puts account ownership in writing, reports on signed cases, and has an attorney approval step for everything it publishes. Walk away from ranking guarantees.

You own the Google Business Profile, analytics, site and content
One named person, and you know how many accounts they carry
Reports tie calls and forms to signed cases
Nothing is published until an attorney approves it
How people look for a lawyer, and what they find
57%of people looking for a lawyer searched on their ownClio, 2019, 2,000 consumers [2]
50%+have used or would consider AI for a legal questionClio, 2025 [2]
40%of law firms answered the phone, down from 56% in 2019Clio, 2024, 500 firms called [1]
33%of law firms replied to an email inquiryClio, 2024 [1]

Most law firms hire an SEO company after a referral and a good sales call. The problems show up six months later: reports nobody can read, content the attorneys never approved, and a Google Business Profile the firm doesn't control. These ten questions surface most of that before you sign. Ask for every answer in writing.

1

Who will do the work, and how many accounts do they carry?

Many agencies sell with a senior strategist and hand the account to a junior coordinator. Ask for the name of the person who answers your emails, who writes the content, who builds links, and how many accounts that person carries at one time. A manager with 15 accounts can give you real attention. One with 40 can't.

Good answerA named person, their account load, and who covers when they're out.
Warning sign"Our team handles it."
2

Who owns the accounts, the website and the content?

Your Google Business Profile, Analytics, Search Console, domain, website and ad accounts should be in the firm's name, with the agency added as a manager. Pages written for you should stay on your site if you leave. Google's own guide to hiring an SEO says an audit needs read-only Search Console access, not write access. [8]

Good answerThe firm owns everything. The agency is a manager you can remove in one click.
Warning signAccounts under the agency's login, or a site on a platform you can't take with you.
3

Do you work with another firm in my practice area and market?

An agency can't put two personal injury firms first in the same city. Some agencies sign competing firms in one market and some offer exclusivity by practice area and county. Either can work, but you should know which one you're buying.

Good answerA written answer: exclusive by practice area and market, or a plain statement of the conflicts.
Warning signNo answer, or "it doesn't matter."

How we do it: our Google Maps engagement takes one business per category per area.

4

What will we see each month, and how are leads tracked to signed cases?

Rankings alone don't pay the bills. A useful report ties search activity to calls and form fills, then to signed cases through your intake or case management software. Ask to see a sample report before you sign. If you can't tell within two minutes what happened last month and what happens next, a year of them won't help.

For local search, ask for map grid reports, which show where you rank across your service area and not from one spot. The handoff counts too: when Clio's researchers contacted 500 law firms in 2024, 40% answered the phone and 33% replied to an email. [1]

Good answerCalls, forms and signed cases by source, call tracking connected to your intake software, and map grid scans.
Warning signTraffic charts and a list of keyword rankings.
5

How is AI used in our content, and who approves it?

Almost every agency uses AI now. The question is how. A good answer: AI helps with research and first drafts, a person edits and fact-checks every page, and an attorney approves it before it goes live. ABA Formal Opinion 512 applies the duties of competence, confidentiality and communication to generative AI tools, and Model Rule 5.3 makes the firm responsible for vendors acting on its behalf. [3][6]

Good answerDrafted with AI, edited and fact-checked by a person, approved by the firm.
Warning sign"We don't use AI" or "it's all automated."
6

What is the plan for Google Maps, reviews and AI answers?

Most small firms should start with the Google Business Profile, because map results drive calls. Ask how the agency handles the profile, reviews and citations, and whether it tracks AI mentions. Two rules to raise on reviews:

  • The FTC's Consumer Review Rule, in force since October 21, 2024, bans fake reviews, incentives that depend on a positive review, undisclosed insider reviews and suppressing negative ones. Penalties run up to $53,088 per violation. [7]
  • ABA Formal Opinion 496 says a negative review does not let a lawyer reveal client information in a reply. It suggests a generic invitation to talk offline, or no reply at all. [5]
Good answerA written plan for the profile, the same review request for every client, replies that never confirm someone was a client, AI mention tracking.
Warning signReview "gating", gift cards for five stars, or replies that discuss the matter.
7

How are links built?

Ask where links will come from and ask to see examples. Good sources for a law firm are bar and legal directories, local organizations, sponsorships, and coverage of real work. Google's spam policies list buying links for ranking purposes as link spam, and a site that breaks them can rank lower or drop out of results. That site is yours, not the agency's. [8]

Good answerNamed link types with examples, reported monthly with the URLs.
Warning signA "proprietary network", or a number of links with no sources.
8

What does the contract say about leaving?

A minimum term isn't automatically a bad sign. SEO takes months, and an agency needs time to show results. Know the term, the notice period, the renewal, and what happens to your content, links and accounts when you leave.

Good answerA short initial term, then month to month. Content and accounts stay with the firm.
Warning signA long auto-renewing term, or content removed on exit.

How we do it: monthly programs start with three months, then run month to month.

9

What results can you document, and who can I call?

Ask for results from firms in your practice area and a market of similar size. A case study from a 40-attorney firm in a major metro tells a solo practitioner very little. Ask what the numbers measure: signed cases and qualified calls mean something, "impressions" and "keywords ranked" on their own do not. Then ask for two references you can phone, including one client who left.

Good answerComparable firms, results in signed cases and calls, and references you can call.
Warning signOnly large-firm case studies, or numbers nobody can check.
10

How do you handle attorney advertising rules?

Your website, your Google Business Profile and your review replies are all attorney advertising, and the firm answers for them whoever wrote them. Model Rule 7.1 bars false or misleading statements about a lawyer's services, Rule 7.2 limits claims of being a certified specialist and paying for recommendations, and Rule 7.3 covers solicitation. Most states have their own versions, so the check has to be against your state's rules. [3][4]

  • Who checks content against our state bar's rules before it is published?
  • Do you avoid "specialist" and "expert" where the state restricts them?
  • How do you present past results and testimonials, and with what disclaimers?
  • How are review replies written so they never confirm someone was a client?
Good answerA named review step before anything is published, and a list of your state's restricted terms.
Warning sign"That's the firm's job."
Try it

Score the agency you're talking to

Mark each answer you got. Nothing is saved or sent.

0 / 200 of 10 answered
Mark the answers you gotTen answers give a score out of 20.

Scoring: in writing 2, vague 1, warning sign 0. Comparing three agencies? The download has a score sheet for that.

How to read the score
17 to 20Strong. Call the references and read the exit terms.
12 to 16Mixed. Get the vague answers in writing first.
0 to 11Keep looking.

Two answers override the score: a warning sign on account ownership or on advertising rules. Settle those before anything else.

Cost

What it costs, and what a quote should itemize

Published price ranges for law firm SEO are agency estimates, not survey data, and they run from a few hundred dollars a month to five figures. Judge a quote two ways: by what it itemizes, and by how many signed cases it takes to pay for itself.

Break-even check
Monthly fee quoted
Average fee per signed case
Cost per year$72,000
Signed cases a year to break even8

That is about one every 7 weeks. Before ad spend and your own intake costs.

A quote should itemize
  • Pages written or rewritten each month
  • Links each month, and where they come from
  • Google Business Profile work and the review process
  • Tracking setup: calls, forms, intake software
  • The report, the meetings, and who runs them
  • Term, notice period, and what you keep
Our prices, for comparison
Google Maps engagementFree for 7 days, then $600/mo ($7,200/yr) or $1,800/mo ($21,600/yr) by grid size
Local SEOFrom $850/mo per location ($10,200/yr)
PPC management$1,000/mo minimum ($12,000/yr) plus $1,500 setup. Ad spend is paid to Google.
Full agency stackRequest a quote
Every price on the packages page »
Timeline

What the first six months should look like

Week 1

Access in the firm's name, a baseline map grid, call and form tracking.

Weeks 2 to 4

Business Profile fixes, citations, a review process. Profile fixes can show within weeks.

Months 2 and 3

Practice-area pages, technical fixes, first links, first full report.

Month 6 on

Competitive practice-area rankings usually take six months or longer.

Red flags

Seven reasons to keep looking

Guaranteed first-page or number-one rankings. Google's guide says to find someone else. [8]
Accounts created under the agency's name
No clear answer on how links are built
Reports with traffic charts but no calls or cases
Content published without attorney review
Paid, gated or staff-written reviews [7]
Tools or methods described as "approved by Google" [8]
FAQ

Frequently asked questions

How much does law firm SEO cost?

It depends on the market, the practice area and what is included, and the ranges agencies publish are their own estimates. Our prices run from $600 a month for Google Maps engagement on one profile to a quoted full program. Whatever the number, ask what it buys page by page and link by link, and work out how many signed cases cover it.

Is the firm responsible for what its SEO company publishes?

Yes. Under ABA Model Rule 5.3 and the state rules based on it, lawyers must make reasonable efforts to see that vendors acting for them follow the conduct rules. That covers content, review replies and chatbots.

How long does SEO take for a law firm?

Google Business Profile fixes can show within weeks. Competitive practice-area rankings usually take six months or longer.

Can an SEO company guarantee first-page rankings?

No. Google's guide to hiring an SEO says that if a company promises first place, you should find someone else.

Should a small firm hire a legal-only agency?

Legal experience helps with advertising rules and intake tracking. What matters more is whether a senior person works on your account and whether the scope fits a firm your size.

What should a law firm own if it leaves an agency?

The website, the domain, the Google Business Profile, Analytics and Search Console, the ad accounts, and every page written for the firm.

Is local SEO or content more important for a law firm?

Most small firms should start with the Google Business Profile and reviews, because map results drive calls. Practice-area pages come next.

Sources
  1. Clio, 2024 Legal Trends Report, secret-shopper study of 500 law firms.
  2. Clio, Legal Trends Report, 2019 consumer survey and 2025 edition.
  3. American Bar Association, Model Rules of Professional Conduct, Rules 5.3, 7.1, 7.2 and 7.3.
  4. ABA Labor and Employment Law, "FAQs: attorney advertising ethics rules in the digital age," Winter 2025.
  5. ABA Formal Opinion 496, Responding to Online Criticism, January 13, 2021.
  6. ABA Formal Opinion 512, Generative Artificial Intelligence Tools, July 29, 2024.
  7. Federal Trade Commission, Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials, 16 CFR Part 465, effective October 21, 2024.
  8. Google Search Central, "Do you need an SEO?" (updated June 2026) and spam policies for Google Search.

This article is general information about hiring a marketing vendor, not legal advice. Check your own state's rules of professional conduct.

Steven Galli, founder of Galli LocalIn digital marketing since 2014. He has led SEO for over 50 clients across nine states, most of them law firms and home-service companies. About Steven
Second opinion

See where your firm ranks before you talk to anyone

The free trial starts with a 5 × 5 map grid scan for your main practice area, back within one business day. Then seven days of our Google Maps ranking work, free.

No contracts. No card. One firm per practice area per market.
Free 7-day trialGoogle Maps rankings · no card